Seville-based Betcat International was prosecuted by the Health & Safety Executive (HSE) after a concerned member of the public raised the alarm.
Betcat was hired by high street clothing chain Mango to carry out refurbishment and alteration works at its store on Market Street, Manchester. The project involved the full refurbishment of the multi-storey store, including structural alterations for the installation of two new staircases, the installation of a lift shaft, and the removal and infilling of an existing stairway.
The site manager was employed by Betcat and all of the site operatives were subcontractors.
When HSE inspectors visited on 29th July 2014, numerous issues were identified.
Two operatives were seen using tower scaffolds which had not been properly erected with full edge protection. One of the tower scaffolds was also balanced at an angle on some steps so that the working platform was not level.
Another operative was seen walking up the new steel staircase from the ground floor to the first floor. The staircase had no handrails or any form of edge protection to prevent falls from height.
On the second floor, a man was standing on a structural steel beam that was spanning the large lift shaft opening in the concrete floor. There was nothing to stop him from falling through to the floor below. The standard of guarding around the opening was poor on each floor and access was not prevented. There were also materials being stored in the area, indicating that operatives were approaching the opening frequently to retrieve materials.
The site was heavily congested with materials, waste and other debris. There seemed to be no clear walkways and the lighting levels were very low.
The toilet had been removed and there was no other toilet on site, nor were there any washing facilities. No other arrangements had been made regarding the provision of welfare facilities whilst the bathroom was being re-tiled and re-plumbed.
An operative was using a small mitre saw that had no guard over the blade. He was pushing timber floor boards through the exposed blade by hand.
A wood saw that was set up for cutting timber products had no dust extraction system fitted and there were piles of dust on all surfaces and large amounts of dust in the air.
There were no fire alarms on site and the only fire extinguishers were out of date, having been left over from the previous shop.
The HSE inspectors served six prohibition notices and two improvement notices, along with a notification of contravention. Trafford Magistrates’ Court heard that all the issues were satisfactorily addressed by the company following HSE’s intervention.
Betcat International Limited, 3 More London Riverside, London SE1 pleaded guilty at Trafford Magistrates Court to breaching Section 2(1) and 3 (1) of the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974 and was fined £40,000 (£20,000 per offence) with £3,761 costs.
HSE inspector Laura Moran said after the case: “Betcat International Limited completely failed in its duty to protect its workers, its subcontractors and visitors to its site from harm.
“Given the range of serious breaches identified, it is very fortunate that nobody was injured or even killed while working on this site. I’d therefore like to thank the member of the public who alerted us to the work, and may well have prevented a serious injury.”